IoT vs SCADA vs MES:
Key Differences and Choosing the Right System
What are the difference things between IoT vs SCADA vs MES ?
In an era where technology plays a pivotal role in advancing manufacturing processes, selecting the right operational system tailored to your business needs is crucial to ensuring product quality. Currently, three widely adopted systems—IoT, SCADA, and MES—are designed to optimize various aspects of production, such as data collection, material management, production tracking, and machine control.
Given the distinct features and capabilities of these systems, understanding their differences can help business operators choose the most suitable one, leading to sustainable improvements in manufacturing processes.
What is the Internet of Things (IoT)?
The Internet of Things (IoT) is a network of devices interconnected through the Internet, using applications or programs to exchange and transmit data. It enhances collaboration among different departments and covers devices such as machinery, computers, and sensors in manufacturing plants, enabling personnel to work more conveniently, efficiently, and quickly.
Key Strengths of IoT Technology
IoT’s main advantage lies in its Internet-based connectivity, integrating various factory data into a unified system. This allows personnel to monitor, operate, and control machines effortlessly, even remotely. For instance, IoT enables functions like turning machines on or off, adjusting their operations, or retrieving specific product data.
What is Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition System (SCADA) ?
SCADA is an industrial control system designed for monitoring and managing large-scale production processes across various departments, even remotely. Its primary role is to provide real-time data visualization related to raw materials, product production, and machine efficiency (OEE).
Strengths of SCADA Systems
SCADA excels in real-time and historical data monitoring, allowing personnel to review data conveniently over different timeframes. Additionally, it features alert systems for abnormalities, enabling quick and accurate problem-solving by operators.
What is Manufacturing Execution System (MES) ?
The Manufacturing Execution System (MES) is a software solution engineered for high-performance production processes. It supports resource planning and operational control across all industrial sectors. Often considered the backbone of Industry 4.0 factories, MES integrates seamlessly with various operational components.
Key Advantages of MES
Implementing MES focuses on core objectives such as resource management, efficiency improvement, process tracking, reporting, and simplifying production processes. MES systems can be applied in all departments, from data collection and production planning to performance measurement and machine monitoring.
Comparison Table: IoT, SCADA, and MES
Business operators can compare the differences among IoT, SCADA, and MES to select the most appropriate system for their needs.
| Difference | IoT | SCADA | MES |
| Working Type | Use the system via internet-connected devices to control operations remotely | Control and monitor machine operation via software | A system that helps manage and improve the efficiency of the production process |
| Objective | Connect data between devices to improve performance | Track and control production processes in real time and retrospectively | Improving efficiency and transparency in production from start to finish |
| Integration | Connect data via the Internet and various types of devices | Connect data through specific networks and sensors | Connect data through other operating systems ex. ERP, PLC or SCADA |
| Data Analysis | Use data for real-time forecasting and monitoring | Analyze data through a old database at the period that you need | Analyze production efficiency and appropriate resource management |
| Production Process Control | Focus on data connectivity rather than production process control | Control machine operation from control center | Focus on planning and controlling the production process |
| System in Manufacturing Industry | To link data between machines and various devices | To control and monitor machines in both real-time and history mode. | To monitor and manage complex processes |
| Example | Temperature sensors, lighting control systems and vehicle tracking systems | Production process control, product quality inspection and preventive maintenance | Production planning, inventory management and tracking of factory worker productivity |
Guidelines for Selecting the Right Technology for Your Business
Although choosing the right technology to transform your industry into a Smart Factory may seem challenging, understanding the factors influencing the decision can make the process manageable:
- Business Requirements: Define the primary goals of installing a system, such as real-time data collection (IoT), process control at the departmental level (SCADA), or managing the entire production process (MES).
- Business Scale: For large factories or those planning to expand operations, MES offers comprehensive solutions for streamlining production processes.
- Production Characteristics: SCADA excels in managing multiple machines simultaneously, while IoT specializes in connecting data from sensors, machines, and devices. MES focuses on overseeing the production process from start to finish.
- Technology Readiness and Investment: Advanced systems like MES and SCADA require significant investments compared to IoT, which is relatively cost-effective.
Conclusion: Elevate Your Industrial Operations with Industry 4.0 Systems
In today’s highly competitive environment, leveraging IoT, SCADA, and MES to transition your manufacturing operations to a Smart Industry is essential for achieving efficient production processes. These technologies help reduce costs, enhance accuracy, and improve competitiveness.
These systems ensure smooth, error-free operations and precise production, making them indispensable tools for modern factories. At ARES, we specialize in consulting and installing operational systems for medium to large-scale factories, empowering businesses to fully embrace the digital manufacturing era.
Contact us
For a demo, please contact us at Contact Us or for further inquiries:
Phone: 0633253640 or 02-6863000 ext. 3042
Email: support@aresth.co.th
Implement ERP: 4 Proven Strategies to Maximize ROI
Learn the 4 key factors for successful ERP implementation—from setting clear goals and managing teams to choosing the right partner.
What is ESG? A Comprehensive Guide for Modern Entrepreneurs
ESG is a business approach focused on three dimensions of sustainability: Environmental, Social, and Governance, aimed at fostering sustainable organizational development and enhancing competitive capabilities.
All You Need to Know About "Factory Systems" for Better Performance in the Modern Era
Factory system management is a critical factor that business owners should prioritize to enhance operational efficiency and establish new standards for their products.